How to Write a Follow-up Email (That Motivates Readers to Click on Reply)

Will Cannon
May 11, 2019
how to write a follow up email

Each day, the average office worker receives 121 emails. Meanwhile, 86% of those workers say that email is their favorite mode of communication. In other words, you have to develop a powerful and effective email strategy to cut through the noise and secure sales. Here’s a closer look at the best ways to write a follow-up email.

Why Do You Need a Strong Email Strategy?

As a modern marketer, you have to be resourceful. Businesses now demand personalized marketing and dynamic results, all on a small budget. In other words, you need to make the most of the key characteristics of emailing.

Popular

Emailing is not only the most tested communication method, but also the most powerful marketing channel available. There are more than 4.3 billion email addresses in the world, and the majority of demographic groups prefer communicating via email.

Visible

Email offers unparalleled reach, and it’s also very visible: 90% of emails get delivered. These statistics trump alternative channels such as Facebook, where just 2% of your followers will organically see your content.

Effective

The click-through rate (CTR) can also be much higher, compared to alternative channels. Of course, the CTR is contingent on a strong strategy and the best follow-up emails possible. Here’s a closer look at ways to achieve a higher CTR.

When to Send a Follow-up Email

In email marketing, timing is a huge factor that will determine whether you’re successful. A 30-minute window could mean the difference between your email being clicked and read, and being deleted without a moment’s hesitation.

There’s a lot of guidance out there about when to send a follow-up email, but it’s important to remember that nothing will be as effective as A/B testing your own data. So it’s essential that you use a quality sales management tools to track statistics and open rates to formulate effective strategies.

But in terms of general advice, here are some of the best tips about timing.

Avoid the Monday Purge

Most professionals start their week by organizing their tasks and sorting through the emails they received while they were away. They’ll often delete anything that appears to be unimportant or unsolicited, so you should avoid sending them emails on Saturdays, Sundays, or Monday mornings.

Also Avoid Fridays

At the end of the week, most professionals spend their time finalizing tasks and thinking about their weekend plans. These professionals aren’t in the right mindset to start thinking about new products or prospects, so it’s better to avoid sending emails on Fridays.

Midweek at 2 pm

According to research conducted by Mailchimp, your best bet for achieving email marketing success is sending emails on Tuesdays, Wednesdays, or Thursdays at around 2 pm.

Break the Mold

However, the following best practices can also be challenging, given that you run the risk of sending your email at the same time as everybody else. In other words, you can reduce the amount of attention your email receives and lower your CTR. Therefore, you should constantly experiment and rely on your data to find the best time to send emails.

How to Write a Follow-Up Email

The subject line, messaging, and structure of your follow-up email will also play a big role in determining how successful you are. Here’s a look at the key steps to writing a fantastic follow-up email.

1. Define the Purpose

First things first. You want to determine exactly why you’re sending your follow-up email. If you have a detailed sales funnel, this step will be much easier.

For example, let’s imagine that a member of your team met with a prospect at an industry event last week. The lead has since gone cold, but you want to move him along the sales funnel. This tactic may mean that your objective is to reinvigorate the relationship.

Now that you have this objective in mind, you can think about how to achieve it via your email. For example, you might decide to send a piece of educational content about your product or service that requests a follow-up conversation.

2. Create a Spectacular Subject Line

With your subject line, you have a small window of opportunity to capture the attention of your recipient. So you have to capitalize on it as much as possible. Here are the features of the best kinds of email subject lines:

Catered

The best subject lines are developed by using quantifiable data. You should make sure that your subject lines are catered to your audience, depending on key demographic information, the device they use, and the email client they prefer.

Short

Data from Marketo suggests that the optimal length of subject lines is currently 41 characters spread across 7 words. While the specifics will vary according to your own data, it gives you a good benchmark to aim for: Keep it short, and find a creative way to get to the point.

Detailed

Your target audience has a limited amount of time, and they want emails that respect these terms. You should make sure that your subject line is as clear as possible, and that it helps your recipient decide whether they want to read it.

Engaging

Finally, you should try to find a way to make the subject line engaging without feeling spammy. Our brains are hardwired to spend extra time and attention on wordplay. In other words, you can capture the attention of your recipient using innovative techniques.

3. Be Direct and Clear

Most email recipients receive an average of 121 emails a day. In other words, you must be brutal about determining whether an email is worthy of readers’  time and attention.

If an email wastes readers’ time, it can have a negative impact on your relationship with your prospect. In other words, you should make sure that every email you send is direct and clear. In the first step, you defined a clear objective for your email, so use it to get right to the point.

Your recipient will appreciate that you respect their time, so you will be much likelier to receive a response. It also helps you build positive feelings.

4. Get Professional Help

Every business delegates responsibilities in different ways. In some companies, sales professionals are responsible for crafting their own follow-up emails. In others, the marketing team might be responsible for creating templates and drafts.

Whichever method you choose to follow, it’s important that your emails maintain top quality. To make sure everything is correct, you’ll want to enlist the help of a copywriter, so you can put your best foot forward by writing an amazing email.

5. Think About the Next Follow-up Email

When it comes to email marketing, perseverance is key. A study from Iko System demonstrates that the sixth email in a marketing sequence can receive a huge boost, in terms of the response rate.

You should structure your email with your sales funnel in mind. If your recipient doesn’t reply to this email, what will the next action be, and how can you organically line it up?

5 Follow-up Email Templates

Looking for some follow-up email templates to kick your email marketing strategy up a notch? Here’s a look at five of the best ones out there:

1. The Short and Sweet Email

This template from Sean Bestor over at Sumo is short and sweet. You can use this template to casually make contact with a prospect after he or she fails to reply.

Hey [First Name],

I hope you had an amazing weekend. I wanted to see what your team thought of my suggestions. Let me know if I can help at all.

All the best,

[Your Name]

We like that this email includes pleasantries, but they’re kept to a minimum as a way to save time. The second sentence is very direct, and the purpose of the email is clear. This email is great if you’re looking for a delicate way to politely reconnect with a prospect.

The Post-Event Email

If you recently attended an event or conference and connected with a prospect, you’ll want to drive home the key messages you discussed and move things forward. This template from HubSpot is very effective:

Dear [Prospect],

What an exciting show! I hope you made great connections and learned some things you can immediately use in your business.

I’m sure that [objective (e.g., effectively increasing sales)] is at the top of your list. As promised, here are [the details of content (e.g., Six Ways to Increase Your Sales)]. If you’d like more in-depth information on any of the ways to implement the [details of content], I’d be delighted to have a 30-minute conversation with you and dive into that.

I’m here to be a resource for you, so don’t hesitate to call me.

Best regards,

[Salesperson]

This post-event email is excellent. It opens with a polite and direct reminder of the meeting, before launching into exactly what the prospect stands to gain. The piece of content is a nice touch. The CTR can be tracked to determine the next action for the prospect. For example, if they click but don’t reply, the next email could ask for feedback about the resource.

There’s also a direct call to action (CTA). In other words, there’s the potential to move the prospect through the sales funnel and take things to the next level.

The CTA Email

Sometimes, you’ll hit an impasse with your email marketing. At that stage, this template from Piotr Zaniewicz from Right Hello could come in handy:

Hi {{Name}},

I see you’re too busy to reply at the moment. Given that, could you just hit me back with the number from the list below (1, 2, or 3) that best describes your response?

  1. Please leave me alone!
  2. Too busy. Email me again in a month.
  3. I’ll reply in a week.

Thanks!

This email is a great way to get a response from a prospect, so you can quickly figure out where you stand. Many prospects will appreciate the direct nature of the email, especially that you’re taking their time into consideration.

The Brutally Honest Email

It’s no fun to receive an endless chain of emails. Rather than inspiring your prospect to act, these emails could possibly turn them away. This template from Dhruv Patel of SalesHandy helps you tactfully ask your prospect to take action:

Hi {{Name}},

I hate pushy salespeople. At the same time, I’d hate to think I gave up on trying to help you when all you needed was one piece of helpful information I forgot to give you. ’

All the best,

Salesperson

This email is a Hail Mary pass that helps you find out exactly what your prospect is hoping for. So it’s a great way to inspire action.

The Information-Packed Email

After an excellent initial call, you’ll want to deliver on your promise to share some extra resources. This template by Neville Medhora from Kopywriting Kourse helps you accomplish this goal:

Hey {{Name}},

It was great meeting this afternoon.

1.) Here’s a handy Business One-pager you can print and send to anyone in the department.

2.) I’ve attached the full slide deck in a PowerPoint presentation.

3.) I’ve also attached the full custom SEO report on your website. Feel free to share this information with the team.

All the best,

Salesperson

As you can see, this email is packed with information, yet it isn’t too heavy. The formatting is simple and clear, which makes it easy to read.

5 Examples of Actual Follow-up Emails

It’s important to try and learn from the best. Here’s a look at five follow-up email examples that have achieved proven results.

Draw Inspiration from Sketch

Draw Inspiration from Sketch

Sketch is a graphic design tool used by thousands of professionals around the world. This tool is unique. After it expires, the user can still use the latest version without renewing his or her license.

This email was sent to existing customers, clearly explains the benefits of Sketch, and offers a direct CTA. The simplicity of the email means that it will be easy for Sketch to track engagement rates, and it articulate the ways small adjustments can lead to improvements.

See how Twilio Shares the Energy

Twilio

In this email, Emerald aimed high: She emailed Howard Schultz directly. By just using plain text, Emerald gives a good indication that the email is a unique one. The list of ideas were great, and they tie into the specific initiatives that Starbucks were running.

Sometimes, a simple, enthusiastic email is all you need! If you do your research and make sure you have what your prospect is looking for, everything will naturally fall into place.

Keep Things Personal

Keep thing personal

This email keeps things personal, and it refers to a shared connection to get things started. It’s a very effective way to get prospects interested and ready to reply. If you have similar ammunition, don’t be afraid to use it!

See How LearnVest Inspires Action

LearnVest

LearnVest is a financial planning tool. While it operates in the B2C space, it has a great post-registration follow-up email. And while the copy is sparse, the design helps customers quickly read through it and get started.

Canva

Canva

Canva is a very popular in-browser tool for graphic design. Its follow-up emails use simple, direct messaging to drive engagement and inspire readers to explore Canva in more detail.

This example shows how content can be intelligently reused throughout email marketing to engage with your audience.

Conclusion

An effective follow-up email is a delicate science. To make informed, appropriate decisions that boost your key metrics, you must leverage data as much as possible. Above all else, treat your recipients with respect, and you’ll be sure to notice improvements.

Also, Check this article by Entrepreneurs life for more tips to reach out clients.

Strategic & Tactical Sales Advice: Straight to Your Inbox.

Join 20,000 sales leaders receiving practical & in-depth content. No fluff, just the best sales how-to guides.

No Responses

Latest Posts